Your 1:1 score

How your score works

What the number on a report means, how it is built, and what it is never used for.

What Vela looks for

Vela reads the transcript for six habits that hold in any workplace.

  • Giving space and listening.Example: letting the person finish before answering.
  • Open questions, one at a time.Example: "What's behind that?" rather than two questions stacked together.
  • Closing loops.Example: coming back to something agreed last time and checking it happened.
  • Hearing concerns.Example: when someone says they are stretched, asking about it instead of moving on.
  • Specific feedback.Example: naming the thing they did that worked, not "nice job".
  • Asking before assigning.Example: checking what is on their plate before handing over new work.

It does not judge tone, directness or formality. Those depend on your company's culture, which Vela cannot see.

It scores the conversation, not you

Each score rates one 1:1 on what is in its transcript. It is not a rating of you as a manager, and a hard conversation can be a good one. If something went well in the room but the transcript missed it, the score will not see it either.

How the number is built

Start at 3+ what raised it− what lowered it= your score
  1. Every 1:1 starts at 3 out of 5. That is a competent, unremarkable conversation.
  2. Vela reads the transcript five times. Each reading lists the moments that stood out, good or not, each tied to one line you said. The readings never write a score.
  3. The code adds each list up with fixed weights, the same for every manager and every conversation. The middle result of the five is the one you see, with that reading's own list of reasons, so the reasons always add up to the number.
  4. The score stays between 1 and 5, in halves.

What raises it

A moment a skilled coach would single out: specific feedback, a concern explored through to a decision, capacity asked about before work was assigned, or a loop deliberately closedhalf a point each, up to one and a half points
A habit you have trained on, handled the way the training intendedhalf a point, a full point if clearly beyond the standard, up to one point
A company value clearly shown, by your company's own definitionhalf a point each, up to one point

What lowers it

A small slip that cost the person nothing real, such as two questions stackedhalf a point
A clear lapse with a real cost: a concern raised and dropped, vague feedback when they asked what worked, or work assigned without asking about capacityone point
A moment that undermines trust: a wellbeing or workload concern ignored or dismissed, being cut off while raising something serious, or work imposed over an objection just voicedtwo points
A company value clearly contradictedhalf a point each, up to one point

One event is charged once. A concern raised and dropped costs once, on the line that dropped it, not again at the end.

Under each score, "Why x/5" lists what raised it, then what lowered it, each with the line from your transcript.

What never changes the score

  • Your company's policies. When one comes up in a 1:1 the report shows it. It never moves the number.
  • Management behaviours your company has written. Shown when they come up, never scored.
  • Anything your direct report wrote. Private feedback goes to a separate step, and the scoring never sees it.
  • Tone, directness or formality.

Company values are the one exception, and only if your company has written them into Vela: a line that clearly shows one adds half a point, a line that clearly contradicts one takes half a point off, up to one point either way. The report names the value and the line.

When Vela will not score

Vela shows this instead of a number:

Not enough in this 1:1 to score it fairly.

That happens when the transcript has fewer than six spoken turns and fewer than 120 words, or when the reading Vela kept found nothing to credit and nothing to question. If fewer than three of the five readings can be read, Vela says "Vela couldn't score this 1:1 reliably this time." rather than showing a number it cannot explain. The report still gives whatever honest feedback it can.

An unscored 1:1 is marked "Not scored" in Your team and History and counts towards no average, chart, pattern or company figure. A longer transcript with no real two-way exchange, where the other person barely speaks, is scored as it stands and lands at 1.

Who can see your scores

Only you. Your direct reports never see your score, your report or anything you wrote. Your company's admins cannot see your score, your quotes, your reports or your coaching, and that is built into how Vela works, not a setting.

The one figure an admin can see is a company-wide average that combines at least five managers' 1:1s, withheld when any one manager makes up more than half of it. Nothing in it can be traced to you.

What scores are for

Vela is for development. Our terms say reports, insights and scores must not be used as evidence in performance reviews, disciplinary processes, pay or promotion decisions, or any process affecting a person's employment.

The honest limits

Five readings do not always agree. Keeping the middle one helps, but the same transcript can still move half a point between runs. A trained habit is credited only once Vela has found that habit in your 1:1s, which needs at least four of them.